I cooked on a $30 nonstick for 12 years. Then my daughter gave me this $89 French pan for my birthday.

My daughter Emily moved to Brooklyn three years ago for graphic design school and has been gently trying to upgrade my kitchen ever since. The KitchenAid was for Christmas 2023. The good knives were for my 52nd birthday. The carbon steel pan — the thing this whole post is about — was for my 54th, this past November.

I want to say first: I am not the kind of woman who needs new kitchen things. I have a Lodge cast iron from my mother. I have a Calphalon nonstick from my second marriage. I have a small saucepan that came with the apartment Tom and I lived in before we bought the house. These pans cook everything the women in my family have ever cooked. They work fine. The nonstick was getting tired but it was still working. I didn't need anything.

Emily gave me the pan with a card that said "trust me, mom" and a printed-out one-page guide to seasoning carbon steel. I left it on the counter for two weeks because I genuinely didn't want to learn a new pan at 54 and I wasn't going to lie to her about using it.

The morning I finally tried it

It was a Tuesday in early December. Tom was at the shop. I was making eggs for myself because I was working from home and the nonstick was in the dishwasher. I picked up the new pan, looked at the one-page guide, and decided that if I was going to do this I might as well actually do it.

Three things surprised me, in this order.

It was light. That was the first thing. My Lodge is a workout to flip. The Calphalon is lighter than the Lodge but I have to use two hands when there's food in it. This new pan I could pick up with one hand and tilt without thinking. It weighed about half what my cast iron does and that was immediately a different kind of cooking.

It heated fast. I'd set the burner to medium-low like the guide said. By the time I'd cracked the eggs into a bowl the pan was hot enough to ripple the oil. I'm used to my cast iron, which takes about four minutes to get to actual searing temperature. This was less than ninety seconds.

And then — the part I'm still telling people about — the eggs slid. Day one. The pan was factory-seasoned, which means whoever makes them in France bakes the oil into the surface before shipping. I didn't have to do anything. The eggs slid off onto my plate the way nonstick eggs do.

What it has and hasn't replaced

It's been eight months and here's the honest pattern of how I cook now:

The Cam pan replaced

• The Calphalon nonstick for eggs, fish, anything I used to need a slick surface for. Same release. Doesn't peel like the nonstick was starting to.
• The Lodge for weeknight steaks and chops. Faster heat-up, lighter to flip, easier cleanup. The Lodge still wins for biscuits and cornbread because of the thermal mass. But for searing one piece of meat for one or two people, this pan is just nicer.
• The Lodge for stir-frying vegetables. Same heat response, lighter to toss. My wrist is grateful.

The Cam pan has NOT replaced

• My Dutch oven for braising or bread.
• The Lodge for the Saturday breakfast pancake-and-bacon routine — that pan goes from cold to hot once and stays hot for an hour, which is exactly what you want for a stack of pancakes.
• My saucepan. Different animal.

So I'm not "replacing my cast iron." I'm using my cast iron less, for fewer specific things, and using the carbon steel for almost everything else. The Lodge isn't going to the basement. The Calphalon nonstick probably is — its days are numbered anyway.

The little things I didn't expect

Cleanup is faster

The pan needs hot water and a stiff brush. No soap unless I cooked fish or something especially greasy. Maybe 45 seconds at the sink and another 30 seconds drying it on the burner and wiping a bit of oil. Total post-cooking routine is under two minutes and most nights I do it while the food rests on plates.

The patina is pretty

It came glossy-black from the factory. Eight months in it's developed a more matte, deeper grey-black with some lighter spots where I cook eggs most often. It looks lived-in in the way a good knife handle does after years of use. I have come to like the way it looks on my stove.

Tom doesn't notice the weight

My husband, who has cooked exactly three meals in this kitchen in 22 years, picked the pan up to move it last week and said "this isn't your cast iron, is it?" without any prompt from me. He thought it was a stainless pan. I told him what it was. He said "huh, that's clever." For Tom that is high praise.

Who I'd actually recommend it to

I am 54 years old, I cook dinner most nights, and I am not interested in being talked into expensive kitchen gear. With that grain of salt, here is who I'd suggest get one of these pans:

If you've been cooking on a tired nonstick and you know in the back of your head you should replace it but don't want another Teflon situation in five years — yes. This is the next pan. It does what the nonstick does, lasts forever, doesn't peel into your food.

If you have one cast iron and you love it but it's heavy and your wrists or shoulders are telling you about it lately — yes. This is half the weight and does most of what the cast iron does.

If you cook for one or two people the 10-inch is plenty. If you cook for a family or like to fit a big steak, get the 12-inch. I now have both and use the 12-inch about 80% of the time.

If you've never cooked on cast iron or carbon steel at all — yes, even more so. Skip the cast iron learning curve. Factory-seasoned carbon steel is the entry path I wish someone had told me about thirty years ago.

What I'd tell Emily

"You were right. Thank you for the pan. I'm sorry I left it on the counter for two weeks." I have not actually said this to her because we don't talk that way, but I will probably send her this article.

If you read this far and you're in that two-weeks-on-the-counter mode I was in last November — try it. Worst case you have a pan that you don't use much. Best case you have the only pan you reach for, eight months later, writing a love letter to it on a Tuesday afternoon.

Check current pricing on Cam Cookware →